That's not fair to Emma. We don't even know what happened after he fell in. We do know that she reached for him. It is actually possible that she fell in, too. Also, back then, there were no cops. Jack was a pilgrim. Even that is besides the point, because Emma was maybe seven years old and her older brother fell into the water. If that happened to me, I would flip out and would probably never skate again. I would be scarred for life. This is also besides the point because, WHAT DID YOU WANT HER TO DO? JUMP IN AFTER HIM? Jack would have died immediately and so would she.
This is what I hate about movies. They always have the big brother save his sister even if he dies trying. I bet my brothers wouldn't do what Jack did in a million years. Now, if you excuse me, I going to lay down from a moment, try not to cry, and up crying anyway. Goodbye. P.S. I love this picture so much. It is beyond perfect.